486 views Filed under: advice or instruction, blogging, writing

3 Ways to Protect Your Content

by Holly Jahangiri on Sep 17th, 2009

Tags Share

 

Comments (18)

Estimated reading time: 8 – 14 minutes

Free, Easy Ways to Detect and Prevent Content Theft

1. Set up an alert system.

Most of the copyright violations I?ve uncovered have been sent directly to my inbox by Google Alerts. There are other sites you can try, as well (such as FairShare, TYNT Tracer, or Copyscape) if you are specifically interested in monitoring the use of your work online.

Google Alerts are free and easy to set up. You can create multiple alerts. Just go to http://www.google.com/alerts:

01-create-alert

Enter your search terms. First, enter the most common variants of your name and public user IDs/email addresses. Enter phrases in quotation marks. For example, if your name is Jane Doe, you won?t want an alert sent to your inbox every time ?Jane? or ?Doe? are mentioned. Try a search like this:

“jane doe”|”jdoe?|?jane e. doe? |?janedoe87?

Choose the type of alert you want to create:

02-type-alert

I like Comprehensive, because it includes all the others. However, if you only want to be alerted when your name is mentioned on someone?s blog, you can narrow the search here.

Next, tell Google how often you?d like to receive your alerts:

03-frequency-alert

Lastly, tell Google how you?d like them delivered ? in your email inbox, or in Google Reader:

03-delivery-alert

You can manage your alerts (change the search terms, the type, the frequency, the delivery method):

05-manage-alert

What other types of alerts are good to have? Here are a few suggestions to get you started:

?<your book title>? AND ?review?

?<your blog title>?

You can use Boolean logic to refine your search terms. The following is an alert that I set up to follow developments around the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act of 2008 and its impact on books:

(cpsia OR “consumer product safety improvement act of 2008″) AND (books OR “holly jahangiri” OR “4RV Publishing”)

This means, ?Send me an alert if the content has either cpsia or the phrase ?consumer product safety improvement act of 2008? and at least ONE of the following words or phrases: books, ?holly jahangiri?, or ?4RV publishing?.? The alerts are not case-sensitive, so you?ll get alerted to cpsia or CPSIA, and so on.

2. Give Notice

Put a copyright notice or Creative Commons notice on your Web site and blog. This is not necessary under current copyright law, and the presumption is that you intend to retain all rights, absent notice to the contrary. However, it provides others with guidance as to how they may use your work. It is both a courtesy and a warning. Many people are honored to have their work ?stolen? ? they see it as a compliment and free exposure or free advertising. And that?s fine, but it would be nice if those folks would clearly label the material that is up for grabs, along with any conditions on using the work (e.g., ?provided you give a link back to my site,? or ?so long as you don?t change anything,? or ?do whatever you want to it, I don?t care?). Don?t embed others? work on your site within an inline frame unless they have clearly consented to that.

Given the very nature of the World Wide Web, it is not reasonable to say, ?Don?t link to my site.? As a courtesy, particularly if your own site has significant traffic, you probably should not link directly to others? graphics (it can chew up bandwidth, and they may be on a bandwidth-limited Web hosting service). You should never copy others? images to your own server, though, without their consent. Consent may be surprisingly easy to obtain, given the nature of the Web. Try asking. Barring that, there are a number of reputable sources for free images on the Web, and the free stock images available are getting better all the time. Or, if you have a friend who enjoys photography, maybe you can work out a deal. For that matter, try taking the photos, yourself. It?s fun!

The Fair Use Doctrine allows for quotations and excerpts (with proper attribution) for education, criticism, or parody. It doesn?t allow you to copy whole blog posts, poems, short stories, or comments and use them on your own site without the author?s permission. But the good news is, there are lots of sites that provide good, free content if you?ve run out of things to say. Try Ezinearticles.com.

3. Take ?em Down!

I know what I said about people thinking it?s cool to be ripped off. I understand the initial reaction ? you?re flattered. Someone liked your stuff enough to steal it. Would you feel that way about your grandmother?s pearl ring? Most copyright violation is the result of automatic content scripting (?scraping? of snippets of content from around the Internet to build a keyword-stuffed page that will display targeted Google Adsense ads and generate search engine traffic that may lead to making a few bucks the lazy, dishonest, unethical way) or deliberate stealing of work by people who don?t have an original thought in their pointy little heads. Don?t be flattered. Nice people either write about you and your content and provide a link back to your site, or they ask if they can use your content on their site. Or they ask you to write something original for them ? a guest post, perhaps. Allowing these folks to get by with stealing from you just encourages them ? and encourages others to imitate them. It?s a bad thing for all of us. But how do you go after them? Half of them aren?t even in the same country!

PlagiarismToday provides extensive resources for fighting back against copyright violations. First, you need to identify the infringer, if possible, and his/her Web host. To identify the host, use a whois lookup tool like http://whois.domaintools.com/. Record the registrant?s contact information, administrative contact information, and legal contact information, if available. Record the name servers, as well ? this is the domain?s web host. You can easily find contact info on most Web hosts? sites, but if not, you can do a whois lookup on them, as well. Next, compose a letter requesting that the infringing material be removed. If you believe that a good faith mistake has been made, you can try to contact the infringer directly. But if you think you?re most likely dealing with someone who committed infringement deliberately, you can proceed straight to the Web host with a DMCA take-down request.

As Jonathan Bailey points out, in his article ?Top 5 DMCA Mistakes,? it?s not always easy. But it?s not always hard, either. I?ve had to file three this week, and response was swift and satisfactory. One was in the Netherlands, so don?t assume that just because the Web host is based overseas and is not subject to U.S. laws like the DMCA, that it can?t be done.

Also, while it is true that you cannot copyright a name, you CAN fight back when your name is used inappropriately and without authorization. I?m not talking about libel here, or an unfavorable review ? I?m talking about sploggers and scrapers that pick up personally identifying information and use it as keywords and meta tags and randomly throw it about on their sites.

This is the response I received from the Abuse department of a Web host where my name appeared on a splog. I had written to them explaining that while I understood this use of my name wasn?t libelous, nor did it constitute a copyright infringement, it was, nonetheless, placed in an inappropriate context that was wholly unauthorized by me:

We define personal Identifying Information as providing a persons First and Last name in conjunction with each other, a phone number, email address, physical address, Social Security Number, etc.? If the material you are requesting to be removed is one or more of the listed items, please fill out the following form.

1. Identification of the material that you are claiming needs to be removed, with information about its location, reasonably specific to permit us to locate the material.

Description of Infringement:

Location of Infringement (Infringing URL or Web Address):

2. Please fill in the following statement:
I _______________________________, have a good faith belief that the disputed use is not authorized by me.

3. Please fill in the following statement:
I _______________________________, swear under penalty of perjury, that the above information in this notification is accurate.

4. The infringement reporter or authorized persons:
Name:
Addresses:
Telephone Number:
Email Address:

5. The electronic/typed or physical signature of the owner of the copyright or the person authorized to act on the owner’s behalf.

6. Please attach a scan of a Government Issued ID.

I filled out all the requested info, emailed it back to them, and within a few hours ? poof! The information was gone. The account was suspended.

If all else fails, and you find yourself dealing with an unresponsive host in a country that doesn?t give a rat?s whiskers about copyright or privacy, you can get creative and have a little fun at their expense, as I did over one repeat offender with my ?Ten Secrets to Hugely Successful Article Writing (Humor)? (I finally figured out that while HE was not in the U.S., his Web hosts were, and they could and did shut him down ? three times!) One thing sploggers should be aware of: If you run someone else?s work through machine translation or some sort of automated text mangling software, and it?s still recognizable, it?s a ?derivative work.? That means it?s STILL protected under copyright law, no matter what your teachers taught you about paraphrasing.

Related Articles

This website uses IntenseDebate comments, but they are not currently loaded because either your browser doesn't support JavaScript, or they didn't load fast enough.

Leave a Comment »18 Comments
  • Reply » jan geronimo September 17, 2009

    That’s a very helpful how-to on going after content scrapers. In your case, the response time was very good. I love your creative suggestion. Serves them right. :)
    .-= jan geronimo hopes you will read…Permission to be Dour =-.

    • Reply » Holly September 17, 2009

      @jan geronimo, the response time was excellent, this week. I was quite pleasantly surprised. It’s rare to have to do three take-down requests in a week, though. I wonder if it was a lingering effect of the recent full moon?

      I should add that there is some risk in trying to be “nice” and contacting these people directly. Some of these folks are criminals, and they’re not going to be really happy with you for shutting down their spurious operations. If you do engage in conversation with them, I would strongly suggest that you be firm, and not let it become an argument or a debate. The one who was using my name in appropriately wrote back to me, unhappy:

      “this is a cache file that i deleted your information and why tell my host this problem, my account suspented because of you :( i have been deleted”

      I’m too soft-hearted, sometimes. I replied:

      That is not true, [name withheld]. I didn’t have to write to you at all – I could have gone straight to your host, and the end result would have been the same. Instead, I tried to give you a chance to correct the problem yourself. You told me that you had deleted the info. I deleted my cache and refreshed my browser to be sure, before I made the screen capture that I sent you. I waited several hours more before contacting your Web host. There was no change to that page. If you had deleted it, as you’d told me you did, it would have been gone.

      A suspension is not a deletion. There is nothing personal in this; provided you don’t use my name or my original works as any part of your site, I won’t stand in the way of your account being reinstated. I would like to know that you respect others enough not to repeat the infringement, and I hope that you will create your own content rather than relying on some automated script to pull names and info from others’ sites. That’s the lazy way to do it, and I have no sympathy if you create your site that way and it gets suspended again. Others may not bother to give you a chance to rectify the mistake before complaining to your host.

      For your information, I did inform them that you had been responsive to my request, but that you either had not or had not been able to delete the offensive material. I did not tell them that you were a bad person; I see no reason why, if you agree to honor their terms of service, they would not reinstate your account. But it was in my best interests to get my name disassociated with that before another day went by.

      Regards,
      Holly

      You can save some time by making sure that your notice to the web host is in the proper format and provides all the required info. Use one of Jonathan Bailey’s form letters, but expect that the Web host may have their own, and may respond with a request to resend the information in a different way.
      .-= Holly hopes you will read…3 Ways to Protect Your Work and Keep from Throwing Your PC Out the Window =-.

      • Reply » jan geronimo September 28, 2009

        @Holly, A splogger scraped my recent post on #followfriday – the whole post. It’s good he didn’t edit the post – my list of related posts pointing to my blog got included. That’s how I found out. Of course, I had not added all possible variations of my blog and username in Google Alert.

        I left a comment, asking him to take down the post. It got published. Imagine that. He’s got his splog on auto-pilot! Ditesco got wind of it and left a comment, warning of consequences if does not delete the post. The scraped post was deleted right away.

        I know I’m lucky that scraper didn’t want to call attention to himself.

        Okay, I’m reviewing the procedures you’ve laid out. Thanks, this is very helpful indeed.

        You’ve got a very pretty Alexa figure now eh? A product of your SEO audit? Google is lusting after you now eh? LOL. Good for you. Congrats!
        .-= jan geronimo hopes you will read…Giving Good Loving To My Top Follow Friday People =-.

        • Reply » Holly Jahangiri September 28, 2009

          @jan geronimo, that’s really amazing, that they responded to you at all. True scrapers and sploggers do generate their content automatically, in most cases, I think – it’s like an unattended mailbox, and your comments either won’t get published or they will, but will be ignored 99% of the time. That you got one who complied quickly, on his own, is remarkable.

          What’s lucky is that your scraper apparently understood the law, somewhat, and complied with it, somewhat.

          And they are lucky that you and DiTesco gave them a chance to remedy the situation personally, rather than going straight to their host. Though I do wonder sometimes if that’s a good approach, on the whole – not all of their victims will find their stolen content, and if they’d do it to you – odds are they’ve done it to others as well. Tough call.

          Sometimes, though, they really do like a particular post – it’s not a splog, but an unoriginal blogger who mistakenly thinks everything on the Internet is free for the taking. (There’s the other extreme, right – where they ask if it’s okay to link to your content. I think that to say “no” to that is to defeat the purpose of the Internet, unless the site doing the linking is a hate site or a porn site.)

  • Reply » Dave Doolin September 17, 2009

    Best post ever on having articles ripped off!

    Kind of wish I had written it myself… sort of… hard to find time to do as much research as required for such excellent posts!
    .-= Dave Doolin hopes you will read…Practical WordPress Tip #11: Spot check your posts =-.

    • Reply » Holly September 17, 2009

      @Dave Doolin, very kind of you to say that. You wouldn’t want to have to do the first-hand “research” I’ve done this week, though, would you?

      Actually, I had to laugh – I was teasing Jonathan Bailey of PlagiarismToday.com that I’d written a post very similar to one of his, but not to think I’d ripped his off, because I didn’t FIND his until I’d posted this one. He has written extensively on this subject, and his site is an absolute goldmine of information if you need it.
      .-= Holly hopes you will read…Wordy Wednesday =-.

  • Reply » DiTesco September 17, 2009

    Yet another great advice Holly. I personally use G Alert for just about anything. Sometimes, I wonder why I get my email full of stuff, and then I remember, ohh.. Red Alert:) Good tip and one that I fully endorse. Everyone should use it.

    Now and about articles or identities being used without consent, I believe we are on the same radar here, as we have previously discussed, lol. You are right though, there are so many free article directories out there that allows you to reprint content, in case you run out of ideas or get the writers block. It is much better than taking the risk of being “Taken Down”, that’s for sure.

    BTW, you might want to change the screenshot where your email appears. You don’t want that wandering around, do you? hehe, have a nice day
    .-= DiTesco hopes you will read…Create Clickable Links In YouTube Videos =-.

    • Reply » Holly Jahangiri September 17, 2009

      @DiTesco, did I mention that my Ukrainian friend was ripping off FREE articles I’d written and posted on EzineArticles? Did I forget to tell the funniest part of the story? How stupid do you have to be, to steal FREE stuff? If he’d just left my bio block on them and not uploaded them to his own “free articles” site under a fake name, I’d have had no issue with him that first time. Second time, he ripped off the articles but mangled them – changed every third word or so to its rough equivalent synonym (assuming it had one, and some didn’t – so it was really garbage, but still had my name in it). Third time, the whole site was unintelligible gibberish – except my name was still there. I couldn’t get his host to respond, so I found a site that taught curse words in Russian and wrote him a little “love note.” I called him a donkey’s behind that obviously spent too much time gazing through the bottom of a vodka bottle.

      He wrote back to me in transliterated Russian. THAT is really hard to get translated, and I spent about a week worrying that maybe he was sending the mob after me. Turns out, he was just wondering why his ripping me off bothered me so much, and telling me he liked wine better than vodka. As if I were going to send him a bottle, or something.

    • Reply » Holly Jahangiri September 17, 2009

      @DiTesco, P.S., I forgot to put my email in the ALT tag. My bad. ;) So sure, yeah, anyone can email me if they’re willing to type that in.

  • Reply » Jena Isle September 28, 2009

    Very useful information, but I’m not really a tickler for this. Perhaps, I’m just too lazy to do the details. When I will have the time and the dedication to see the process through until it gets done. I’ll do all these pointers. Thanks for these very vital pointers.

    By the way, I have created a link from my Gewgaw blog to this article. I know bloggers will find it useful. Is that okay with you? If not, kindly inform. Thanks.
    .-= Jena Isle hopes you will read…PUFFY WHITES =-.

    • Reply » Holly Jahangiri September 28, 2009

      @Jena Isle, you may link to anything of mine you like, Jena – you needn’t even ask (since I know you’re not a splogger, scraper, hater, porn promulgator, or purveyor of spam). I’m always honored to have you link to my blog, you know that.

  • Reply » Dragon Blogger October 14, 2009

    Really good article, just retweeted for my tweeps, it should be a must read for bloggers.
    .-= Dragon Blogger hopes you will read…Top October Searches for Dragon Blogger =-.

  • Reply » Ching Ya December 24, 2009

    I remember writing a post about content theft after researching for solutions to this problem months back. It’s such a shame that people would actually steal content and claim their own! A very nice effort, Holly. You have my support on this subject and I’m RT-ing this for sure.

    Merry Christmas!

    @wchingya
    Social/Blogging Tracker
    .-= Ching Ya hopes you will read…How to Brand Your Tweets with TweetBrand =-.

    • Reply » Holly Jahangiri December 24, 2009

      Thank you, Ching Ya!

      I think most people don’t realize it is theft; then again, I know a number of them who will argue the point until they’re blue in the face, then when proven wrong will just say “So what?” Those are the ones that make me really angry.

  • Reply » Linda Jackson January 5, 2010

    Hi Holly,

    Sire told me to read your post and it was very useful. I wish my thief would remove my content but they don't reply and don't remove it. As I said to Sire I'm worried about them being vengeful, because unfortunately they know its me requesting the removal.

    At least with your excellent post I can do more to watch in the future.
    My recent post Three Popular Celebrity Scents To Excite The Senses

    • Reply » HollyJahangiri January 6, 2010

      They'll always know it's you, because ONLY the copyright holder or authorized representative can file a DMCA take-down request. But what are they going to do? Bad-mouth you? Take screen-shots of their theft of your work, first.

Get a GravatarLeave a Reply

Name: « Required

Email Address: « Required

Website URL: « Optional

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Subscribe by Email

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Categories
ss_blog_claim=a7582b85a064308846dffd2585b7270f